What is Jimmy Mustard?

Have you heard about Jimmy Mustard, but are not entirely sure what is it? Is it vegan? Is it healthy? Read on and discover.
Sibta Mashail, RDN

Written by Sibta Mashail, RDN. Updated on November 30, 2022.

Are you stopping by Jimmy John’s restaurant to enjoy your favorite sandwich? If asked, “Would you like Dijon or spicy House Mustard?” go for the Crunchy Jimmy Mustard and you will not regret trying it out.

It’s one of the condiments worth buying that Jimmy John’s offers. You will get convinced by discovering all about this flavorful mustard here.t

Whether it’s yellow mustard or Grey Poupon Dijon mustard, these taste slightly different from Jimmy Mustard. Jimmy John’s has its own innovation!

Where does this name come from? It’s prepared by the popular American restaurant chain “Jimmy John’s” which is famous for its sandwiches, cuts, and sauces.

What makes it so remarkable and delicious is its extraordinary flavor, texture, spice, and heat. Let’s indulge in the mustard world to get the best one out of Jimmy Mustard and Dijon Mustard.

Is Jimmy Mustard Vegan?

Yes, it is a vegan condiment that is famously sold at the sandwich restaurant chain named Jimmy Johns.

It’s the mixture of tasty spices that is for making sandwiches or dipping savory French fries. This company also offers other vegan-friendly products such as Grey Poupon.

If you are craving a quick filling then Jimmy John can fulfill your desire!

Does Jimmy John make a sandwich for vegan consumers?

Jimmy John’s offers consumers a variety of vegan options to attract their customers. These vegan options include:

  • Veggie sub-without mayo and cheese
  • Bread-wheat and French bread
  • Vegetable toppings- include lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, onion, pickles, Jimmy peppers
  • Spreads- Avocado, Jimmy mustard, Grey Poupon, Yellow mustard sauces
  • Variety of chips

If you’ve been a vegan consumer for a long time, you must properly investigate between vegan and non-vegan foods. Sometimes non-vegan foods are sneaked into vegan foods and considered to be vegan-friendly foods.

Dijon Mustard Vs Jimmy Mustard

Have you felt the texture Jimmy Mustard puts on your tongue?

Jimmy Mustard provides gourmet flavor as it is prepared with a whole grain of brown mustard giving an extra kick of savor to your taste buds with whole seeds in it while Dijon Mustard is smoother in texture using ground mustard seeds taking it to the tangier side.

Having that said, brown mustard seeds are spicier providing more heat to the Jimmy Mustard, and soaked in vinegar to get some more flavor.

However, dijon mustard seeds have that flavored sharpness in themselves and these are soaked in mild liquids which makes their tastes a bit different from each other.

Is Jimmy Mustard Healthy?

As its source is mustard seeds, nothing makes it unhealthy. But How about the preservatives? Jimmy Johns claims to provide all the nutrition and Allergen information including Jimmy Mustard which is free from all allergens and preservatives too.

This makes it a healthier option though. No MSG, no preservatives, nitrites, or nitrates are added in the mustard along with the other menu of Jimmy John’s and prepared from scratch.

However, grey Poupon dijon mustard and yellow mustard might have allergens like peanuts or other tree nuts. If you are allergic to these products, Jimmy Mustard is a go-to mustard option.

Is Jimmy Mustard Pocket Friendly?

Evaluating the flavors, texture, and nutrition of both mustards, how can you forget their purchasing cost? Is it pocket-friendly or not?

Well, if you buy Jimmy Mustard directly from Jimmy John’s franchise, it would cost you $17. The prices may vary from other grocery stores as it’s not fixed. It’s still cheaper if we compare it to other brown mustards.

Likewise, if you buy Dijon Mustard from the grocery store, it would cost you around $10 for a 32 ounces jar. This sounds more affordable!

Jimmy vs Dijon Mustard Nutrition

Nutritional FactsJimmy MustardDijon Mustard
Total Fats0g0.2g
Saturated fats0g0g
Trans fats0g0g
Polyunsaturated fat0g0g
Monounsaturated fat0g0g
Total Carbohydrates0g0.3g
Dietary Fiber0g0.2g

The nutrition of Jimmy mustard can be comparable to dijon because its spiciness gives more heat to start with. It’s milder than the original Grey Poupon.

Whereas the taste of dijon mustard might surpass sandwiches and seems too savory due to its nutrition. Jimmy mustard is considered to be flavorful and it can be used for a variety of foods.

Beginning from burgers to sandwiches, it can be a great combination for any type of meal.

How to Make Jimmy Mustard at Home?

Do you know how to prepare Jimmy mustard? Well, you can create your version. For ingredients, Jimmy John does not expose their Jimmy mustard recipe.

So we are not sure but it’s really fun to experiment with something new and try the recipes at home. In the beginning, it won’t be perfect as you want but in the end, after trying several times the result would probably taste good.

Learning to create sauces on your own is a simple task and a rewarding procedure that generates a maximum effect on your taste buds.

Starting from the simple to the most difficult recipes, these ingredients are really helpful for you to try at home.

The list of Jimmy mustard ingredients is listed below.


  • ¾ cup of yellow mustard seeds
  • 1 cup water
  • ¼ cup vinegar
  • ½ tsp salt
  • ¼ tsp turmeric powder
  • ¼ tsp garlic powder
  • ¼ tsp paprika
  • ¼ tsp onion powder

By using these ingredients it can be fun to experience a great way to create flavourful mustard for your food. However, in most cases, homemade foods are much healthier than store-made alternatives.

The main tip for making Jimmy mustard at home is to control the ingredients you use. You choose to prepare it as mild or spicy as per your preference. Yet, store-bought ingredients are overpowered like too much vinegar, salt, etc.


Focusing on sensory factors, nutrition, and affordability, the delicious Jimmy Mustard is incredible in all ways.

If you miss the Old School Deli Mustard as mentioned on the jar, then Jimmy mustard is a forever yay.

How we ensure this article is accurate?
  1. It's written and or reviewed by an expert.
  2. We cite relevant studies and trusted sources.
  3. It's regularly updated.

Read more about our process and team.